Please take the time to vote for one player from each position.
The top three players who receive the most votes will be chosen to represent their respective conference at their position.
EASTERN CONFERENCE LW
ix-RaiN-iv wrote:Mes is just a beast (also dont forget its a popularity contest in the end)
AggroCrag24 wrote:ix-RaiN-iv wrote:Mes is just a beast (also dont forget its a popularity contest in the end)
All-Star voting shouldn't have player names next season. Just their stats and teams position in the standings. Maybe we will get a more fair vote.
Class_Act_27 wrote:It's becoming "let's pick the worst guy on the list and vote him in"
AggroCrag24 wrote:All-Star voting shouldn't have player names next season. Just their stats and teams position in the standings. Maybe we will get a more fair vote.
fluri37 wrote:maybe just do voting by committee, either make the NHL GMs vote on one player at each position from your list (and say that they cant vote for themselves or someone on their team) or have staff vote on it or something. Really only way you can make it fair IMO.
meMack wrote:AggroCrag24 wrote:All-Star voting shouldn't have player names next season. Just their stats and teams position in the standings. Maybe we will get a more fair vote.
Then ppl whould just match the stats to the players names and will be saying "Vote For Me #3" for blah blah blah..
The League has
-picked the ASG lines, and everyone complained "XXX shouldnt be there YYY should"
- Changed to voting system to MVG one season so ppl had to register to vote, and ppl hacked the sysytem and created fake accounts
-We have game minimums and some ppl say it should be higher, and some say it should be lower so they can get in
You catching the drift??? Damned if ya do, Damned if ya don't. No matter what is done, there will always be someone complaining and trying to manipulate the system because they feel making the ASG is a badge of honor, no matter how they get it or if they deserve it.
Its a popular vote, you can tell each time the ASG comes around now, as ppl campaign for votes on twitter, chatroom, psn, skype and post in their team pages to vote for teammates.
Yes, I agree, it would be great if it was 100% based on merit, and it went to the player who is having the best season at that position, and players voted that way, but whats the chance of that..
CastroGstar wrote:And then the committee would be blamed for picking the wrong people and having favorites.
The top eight people are chosen for each position; those are the facts. If people aren't happy about that then that's their problem.
The VGHL all star games, like in real life, are for the people. We try to create a fun environment for our community to join in on and give our top vote getter a prize. All voting environments, from sports to politics, boil down to a popularity contest amongst the best candidates.
No matter how the process is handled people will still complain if they feel that their personal opinions have not been respected.
Instead of complaining, congratulate everyone that made the lists. Once the lines are finalized, cheer for the teams that represents your conference so that your team can have home ice advantage if they advance to the Finals.
Kcrusher33 wrote:See this system the way it is you kind of already have the best in both worlds. The list is comprised of Merit. Then the community votes. I in the end it ususally ends up being most talented first line popular guy 2nd line. I'm still not seeing an issue here. Ovi is winning his Socca winning LD. And guys like myself and Mes might get in popularity even though we got nominated on what we've done this season. Merit.
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum